3) All-Star Michele Dee defeated Skylar to win the title (4/12/25 @ Rec Center, Nutley, NJ)

​​​

   - Title vacated by Vicki due to injury (2024)

 

2) Vivacious Vicki def. Notorious Mimi and All-Star Michele Dee to win vacant title in Triple Threat Elimination Match (8/22/21 @ Rec Center, Nutley, NJ)

 

   - Title vacated by Tasha Steelz upon signing with IMPACT Wrestling (2020)

 

1) Tasha Steelz def. All-Star Michele Dee and Red Hot Erin Winter to become first-ever IWF Women's Champion in Triple Threat Elimination Match (4/16/16 @ Rec Center, Nutley, NJ)